Titre original : Paradise Lost
Pressured to reach the quota by the end of the week, Eli launches an expedition to find more kids to bring to the base. While the snatchers search for kids in the community, Jarrah attempts to steal their boat. The snatchers come back with Zuke before she is able to get away, so Jarrah allows herself to be captured in order to save her brother. On the boat, Jarrah manages to stop the engine so Zuke can escape. Jarrah is taken to the base. Meanwhile, drama continues with Natasha, Eli and Ryan. Saskia, upset with Eli’s expedition, tricks Eli into telling her about that he didn't really like Natasha while Natasha is listening. After realizing that Eli was just using her, Natasha apologizes to Ryan. When Ryan finds out that Natasha approved the snatchers going back to the community, however, he breaks up with Natasha.